Deobandi, Barelvi &c
Posted on Sunday, 27th July 2008 @ 3:45pm
Hi everyone
Hope you can help me. I'm working on a research project and can't find the Islamic word for the different schools of thought, be they Deobandi, Barevi, Salafi &c. Basically, if you were trying to ask someone (in Urdu or Arabic, say) whether they were a Deobandi or a Barelvi or whatever what would the BLANK be in the following sentence: What BLANK are you?
(I suppose the analogy with Hinduism is that people might ask which caste you were, and the BLANK would be whatever the Hindi word for caste is.)
Hope I've explained that well (not sure I have), but hope you can help me and many thanks in advance.
Sam
24 June 2005
2 hours 40 min
They are not schools of thought. Schools of thought are like hanafi, Maliki, Hanbali (Ja'afri) and Sha'afi.
What you mentioned are groups/sects.
The enemy of my enemy is my... enemy.
4 May 2008
18 weeks 1 day
Thanks for correcting me on that, You; that's really helpful. I suppose I'm just looking for the Arabic word for 'group' or 'sect' in this context, then?
Thanks again, Sam
Have a biscuit.
31 March 2008
8 hours 6 min
i can give you the urdu word for 'sect': Firka
but it doesn't really apply in the above mentioned context...
Sky's the limit. True or false?
19 August 2007
3 weeks 2 days
The Arabic word is Madhab. There are four of them, Hanafi, Shafi, Maliki and Hambali.
Chin up, mate! Life's too short.
25 June 2005
12 hours 51 sec
Salam
Sam, if you don't mind, I would like to request that
before posting, please do take a little time to read other topics.
It would help you a lot Sam.
I know they have placed blinkers on you,
but trust me, they are not hard to take off.
Remove them and you will a whole lot more of our wonderful world.
Sam. You're a man, not a horse.
http://www.therevival.co.uk/forum/general/3974
Play it again Sam.
Omrow
---
19 August 2007
3 weeks 2 days
But he didn't know what Madhab meant did he?
Chin up, mate! Life's too short.
25 June 2005
12 hours 51 sec
Had he bothered to actually read that thread,
he would not have needed you do defend him now.
---
19 August 2007
3 weeks 2 days
If he doesn't know what Madhab meant then why would he read it?
Chin up, mate! Life's too short.
25 June 2005
12 hours 51 sec
If Sam removed his blinkers, he would have known.
---
19 August 2007
3 weeks 2 days
Mate, do you enjoy being spiteful to people? He didn't know what a Madhab was so that thread didn't attract his attention. Can't you just accept it? Or are you really that bored?
Chin up, mate! Life's too short.
4 May 2008
18 weeks 1 day
Thanks for that, love to live but living to die. Firka might not be quite the right word in this context, but it's very useful to know anyway.
Courage, Madhab it is, then! Many, many thanks. Much appreciated, especially the extra information listing the different Madhabs.
All best
Sam
Have a biscuit.
31 March 2008
8 hours 6 min
i think Omrow comes on the forum only when he's having a bad day! wouldn't you agree?
Sky's the limit. True or false?
19 August 2007
3 weeks 2 days
You're learning fast.
Chin up, mate! Life's too short.
8 August 2006
1 week 1 day
Brelvi, Deobandi, salafi etc are not madhabs.
As a matter of fact, both Brelvi and Deobandi follow Hanafi fiqh.
They are just Muslim groups. Generally originating from the teachings and methods and views adopted by specific scholars.
May Allah shine sweet faith upon you this day and times beyond. May your heart be enriched with peace, and may your home be blessed always. Ameen.
Salam
You could use the term Manhaj. For example what is your Minhaj/Manhaj something along those lines.
19 August 2007
3 weeks 2 days
You're early.
Chin up, mate! Life's too short.