Shariah law & Crime
Is there any leniency with the punishments? Or does every crime have to be punished?
Does context matter? E.g. would a poor person still have his hand cut off for stealing
What kind of punishments are given and for what crimes?
Forum
44 comments
TPOS Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 11:07
Re: Shariah law & Crime
Lilly had missed the point...
I was asking if Shariah law takes mitigating factors into account when a decision is made.
The Lamp Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 14:22
Re: Shariah law & Crime
Yeah, certainly, that was definitely what Umar bin Khattab did. We can take precedence from that.
lollywood Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 16:30
Re: Shariah law & Crime
Sharia law is barbaric
[video:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-h_RaXdvlTY[/video]
TPOS Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 16:44
Re: Shariah law & Crime
:roll:
You Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 18:34
Re: Shariah law & Crime
That video isnt shariah.
Sharia would actually prevent that.
Ergo, Sharia law is quite humane.
lollywood Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 18:39
Re: Shariah law & Crime
Sharia law is unfair in someways
Sharia law can not work
You Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 18:48
Re: Shariah law & Crime
Not the same as the male as more responsibilities and MUST provide for the women, while a womans inheritence he her own and only her own.
I wouldnt advise anyone to take such an option, man or woman. What are the chances of bringing up the kids in a good environment?
and if she disagrees she has the right of refusal and the marriage is not valid without her permission. and this only applies to young people, just like how 16 and 17 year olds in UK law cannot marry without the consent of their parents but 18 year olds can.
I dont see any issue with this.
give and take. He also has greater inheritance to account for such things.
except that it does and even UK common law is modeled on maliki fiqh.
TPOS Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 18:49
Re: Shariah law & Crime
To understand shariah law you have to first accept men and women are not the same. They are different and so have different roles.
Really? Interesting. Where can I read more on this?
lollywood Wed, 4 Apr 2012 - 19:36
Re: Shariah law & Crime
Why can't she share it with her husband?
Its the people who make environment good or bad
Come on.... what are the chances of that happening?
Mom has given you that scary desi look before the nikah its a frown with eyes popping out through gritted teeth and then the usual blackmail in urdu
Agar tum ne ye shadi na ki to khandan wale humein taane dein ge
in Engish it would be saying the family is going to taunt us if you don't marry our chosen partner
If she has refused which I have never heard or seen of in real life I've only seen it in Lollywood films then they say
Tum ne hamari naak katwa di
In English it would be like saying that you have cut off our noise but you could translate it as you have brought shame on the family and this shame has often lead to murder like the Shafilia Ahmed case
But in Islam girls can marry as young as 9
Why is she not asked to share her wealth when the man is?
Are you sure?
lollywood Thu, 5 Apr 2012 - 17:38
Re: Shariah law & Crime
Why should the man be made too?
Freedom?
You’re joking right
A women can only go out if she has a male member accompanying her she still has to be covered up head to toe even the face has to be covered in some case's, in Saudi a women is not allowed to drive in this day and age- they just got the permission to vote only a few weeks ago, if that's what you call freedom then I dread to think what oppression would be like
I'm not sure about that
Saying no is not an option with Asian families Bangladesh, India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka
the -Izzat- card comes out that would make you agree and if you still didn't then they would trick you in going back to Bangladesh when you get there they would force you as much as they can because the law can be brought in Asian countries so they would not be worried about being locked up – example the British Bangladeshi doctor Humaira Abidin she was forced to marry in Bangladesh
Have you seen any case where the parents have agreed?
First you said they can't then you yourself said they can, don't you think that's wrong?
Lets say a girl does reach puberty at 9 in an Asian country because its hot and she’s made to marry a 25 or 30 year old man how an earth is that justifiable? why did Islam allow this sort of thing? how is that giving girls -women freedom its enslaving them at a young age not to mention if she gets pregnant at a young age that could be a risk to her health it may even kill her if it doesn’t then it gives her the added responsibility at a young age when it should be her time to get an education play with her friends and not be worried about these things
ok
what if we get Sharia law in this country?
If the woman was worried about stigma I don't think she would get divorced in the first place I know many Muslim women who are only living with their husbands because they don't want to leave the kids or they want the kids to grow up with both parents and they don't want to be seen as divorced because in some cultures its the women who is seen as wrong even if it's not here fault
lollywood Fri, 6 Apr 2012 - 17:47
Re: Shariah law & Crime
Ok what if the man serious injures himself in an accident and is unable to work then why can’t the wife use her wealth to help him out?
It still is, it has a very bad human rights record women are still stoned and executed
Son taking his fathers wives is to do with keeping money in the family still Muslims get married within the family
Girls are still buried alive in some parts of Sindh Pakistan
Its still the same in most Muslim countries
I don't think it did or if it did it gave with one hand and took with thw other
Burqa has to be worn in all weathers hot or cold- is that freedom?
women have to go out with a male family member mehram they can't go out on their own, they can't drive, they can't mix or talk with non mehrams under sharia law is that freedom?
I think it has Sharia law
No Muslim country is a good example that's why you see Muslims running to western countries or they want western democracy and life style in the land they're living in that's what their dyin for
They would do anything to get here, in some villages they don't know a word of English but they seem to know me going the englaand no here good bad saddam, bad gadafi bad bashar ul asad he killing people If you gave them a choice between Islam or a western country to live in I'd say they would chose the western country because Muslims have started to realise that Islam has failed and failed miserably in almost every state its in
But western women don't put up with any crap, 1 word and out the door they go, they couldn’t give a stuff about the kids or what the family and society are going to say about them
Ok
They get tricked into going back grandma’s ill uncle's getting married or we want to show you our culture
This is just what i mean you have a fear of going back
I was saying that they don't agree, what usually happens is that the children ran way have a 1 yr old child together then the parents find out about the child then they come to their senses and agree to the marriage its never lets respect the choive of our children and let them marry who ever they want
Because 9 is too young
Have you ever heard of a non Muslim girl getting married at 9 10 11 12?
I have heard of many case's when 80 yr old man marry 9 yr old girls mostly in Saudi and south asian countries
That's impossible
No it's not the families choice they follow the Quran the Quran says marry your daughter asap
Young girls would not understand the responsibilities that come with marriage kids being one of them
You won’t be able to fully concentrate you’d be thinking about house work that needs doing shopping that needs buying, food that needs cooking cloths that need ironing
16 and marriage no way
I don't think Asian women would do that... the usual
Sabr shukr teaching would come from the parents and the girl would just bear it
LookingToSee Fri, 6 Apr 2012 - 20:24
Re: Shariah law & Crime
did i write this? i dont remember writing this. O.O
TPOS Fri, 6 Apr 2012 - 22:39
Re: Shariah law & Crime
You be silly Lilly :p
LookingToSee Fri, 6 Apr 2012 - 22:51
Re: Shariah law & Crime
i be insane sister..
Pagination
Comments are closed on this post.