Isn't wearing makeup haram?

Raj โ€”

I have seen many Muslim girls wear makeup and also have a hijab on. I mean thats just silly. They are not only bringing gunnah on themselves, but they are making "pious" Muslims like me sin by looking at them.

They should cover up fully. Or I need to get married so I can apply this hadeeth to my person life:

A woman advances and retires in the shape of a devil; so when one of you sees a woman, he should come to his wife and have intercourse with herโ€ฆ(Shahih Muslim 8.3240) ๐Ÿ˜‰

Forum
General

Foysol89 โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 22:55

This is going onto another topic which i don't really want to do cause it may annoy people.

To answer your question though what more can be done in grooming apart from just making yourself look presentable (for men that is)? What kinda makeup would men wear?

Don't get me wrong i'm all for looking good, i always make an effort ๐Ÿ˜‰

You โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 22:59

People with white hair were encouraged to colour it.

Surma for the eyes, and its not JUST because it had health properties.

At the conquest of Makkah, the prophet ๏ทบ had his hair in 3 plaids.

I think there is a hadith on the line of "God is beautiful and likes beautiful things".

TPOS โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:02

Noor

Lol. Make up doesn't go in and out of season, that's clothes and shoes. People have always wore make up.

It does go out of season since shops/companies have 'summer' collections and 'winter' collections etc. I know people who wear a certain colour in one season and a different in another :/

TPOS โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:09

Calm down, he clearly said it was his opinion and he obviously doesn't know from a women's perspective. Nothing wrong with sharing your opinion - it didn't need to be challenged in such a harsh manner :/

(I had deleted this earlier but re-writing it)

Noor โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:10

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcE

Noor

Lol. Make up doesn't go in and out of season, that's clothes and shoes. People have always wore make up.

It does go out of season since shops/companies have 'summer' collections and 'winter' collections etc. I know people who wear a certain colour in one season and a different in another :/

It's all the same.

Noor โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:11

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcECalm down, he clearly said it was his opinion and he obviously doesn't know from a women's perspective. Nothing wrong with sharing your opinion - it didn't need to be challenged in such a harsh manner :/

(I had deleted this earlier but re-writing it)

It was baseless so what was the point of saying anything in the first place?

TPOS โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:22

Noor

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcE
Noor

Lol. Make up doesn't go in and out of season, that's clothes and shoes. People have always wore make up.

It does go out of season since shops/companies have 'summer' collections and 'winter' collections etc. I know people who wear a certain colour in one season and a different in another :/

It's all the same.

Clearly some people feel different shades work better in different times of the year. And that is based on 'advice' from what the company/mags/models/'specialists' etc show and say looks better and is 'in'/ 'fashionable'

Therefore Foysol's comment is not baseless.

So what if it was baseless, like I said, you could've challenged him less harshly.

Noor โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:22

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcEClearly some people feel different shades work better in different times of the year. And that is based on 'advice' from what the company/mags/models/'specialists' etc show and say looks better and is 'in'/ 'fashionable'

Because they want you to buy the products, most make up sale advisors work on commission so they will say anything to make you buy the products.

And if you look at the make up it is exactly the same other than the floral box/packaging for summer.

TPOS โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:22

Noor

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcEClearly some people feel different shades work better in different times of the year. And that is based on 'advice' from what the company/mags/models/'specialists' etc show and say looks better and is 'in'/ 'fashionable'

Because they want you to buy the products, most make up sale advisors work on commission so they will say anything to make you buy the products.

And if you look at the make up it is exactly the same other than the floral box/packaging for summer.

That doesn't refute my actual point :/

Noor โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:25

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcE
Therefore Foysol's comment is not baseless.

So what if it was baseless, like I said, you could've challenged him less harshly.

Make your mind up, was it or wasn't it?

Of course it was baseless, what did he base anything he said on? He hadn't asked any woman about why they wear make up etc.

And i didn't challenge him harshly. Just made it crystal clear.

Noor โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:26

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcE

Noor
ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcEClearly some people feel different shades work better in different times of the year. And that is based on 'advice' from what the company/mags/models/'specialists' etc show and say looks better and is 'in'/ 'fashionable'

Because they want you to buy the products, most make up sale advisors work on commission so they will say anything to make you buy the products.

And if you look at the make up it is exactly the same other than the floral box/packaging for summer.

That doesn't refute my actual point :/

Whatever.

TPOS โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:31

Noor

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcE
Therefore Foysol's comment is not baseless.

So what if it was baseless, like I said, you could've challenged him less harshly.

Make your mind up, was it or wasn't it?

Of course it was baseless, what did he base anything he said on? He hadn't asked any woman about why they wear make up etc.

And i didn't challenge him harshly. Just made it crystal clear.

I meant if it was/if you think it was. I don't think it was.

And you replied like rudely and crazily defensive for no reason.

Noor โ€” Fri, 17 Jun 2011 - 23:33

Lol. Where was i rude or defensive?

I was just making a point.

He just made baseless assumptions and i cleared that up.

Bilan โ€” Sat, 18 Jun 2011 - 16:01

YouWhat do you consider a decent amount of grooming/makeup?

(because this is just a friendly discussion, I will tell you my aim - to show you that even the prophet ๏ทบ himself may have done more than what you consider the decent amount.)

What IS the decent amount of make-up allowed?

I have to say, I find the thought of wearing make-up inside the house strange...

LookingToSee โ€” Sat, 18 Jun 2011 - 17:10

bilan

YouWhat do you consider a decent amount of grooming/makeup?

(because this is just a friendly discussion, I will tell you my aim - to show you that even the prophet ๏ทบ himself may have done more than what you consider the decent amount.)

What IS the decent amount of make-up allowed?

I have to say, I find the thought of wearing make-up inside the house strange...

why?

Bilan โ€” Sat, 18 Jun 2011 - 17:34

Lilly

bilan
YouWhat do you consider a decent amount of grooming/makeup?

(because this is just a friendly discussion, I will tell you my aim - to show you that even the prophet ๏ทบ himself may have done more than what you consider the decent amount.)

What IS the decent amount of make-up allowed?

I have to say, I find the thought of wearing make-up inside the house strange...

why?

Cos I dont normally wear it unless at weddings, which is like twice a year? Well maybe not strange, but uncomfortable to wear in the house and I wouldnt wanna feel uncomfortable in my own home. Actually, no I do find it weird, the way Im imagining it in my head...

Angel In Disguise โ€” Sat, 18 Jun 2011 - 18:20

Raj

*_Noor_*Well what do you think???? mascara in it self isnt haraam, Allah swt doesnt say its haraam as i sed its the way u wear it, you can get differnt types, sum which are very dark and some which are light, and for lip gloss, is Vaseline haraam? its more a less the same thing. its hwo you wear it!!!!!! get it in your head!!! and if you tried to lower your gaze you wouldnt be asking stuch stupid questions!

Well today I'd seen a really beautiful Muslim girl she had a hijab and she looked intoxicating. If she was covered up properly, and didn't have the make up on as she did. I wouldn't be thinking about her right now. Actually she was very beautiful I can never forget her face.

YOU ARE DISGUSTING.

Angel In Disguise โ€” Sat, 18 Jun 2011 - 18:23

Noorthe guyz got sum serious issues

I soo agree, what kind of topic is this?
First he asks if wearing make up is haraam, if it is how would it benefit him
he wouldnt have noticed females wearing it in the first place if he wasnt perving ... FREAKO!

TPOS โ€” Sat, 18 Jun 2011 - 18:54

Angel In Disguise
First he asks if wearing make up is haraam, if it is how would it benefit him
he wouldnt have noticed females wearing it in the first place if he wasnt perving ... FREAKO!

not talking about this guy in particular but generally men and women should know about the issues concerning the other so they can teach their wife/husband/siblings/children etc, I think.

Also I don't think you have to really stare to notice the make up, sometimes (or generally) it just noticeable.

Bilan โ€” Sat, 18 Jun 2011 - 19:38

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcE

Angel In Disguise
First he asks if wearing make up is haraam, if it is how would it benefit him
he wouldnt have noticed females wearing it in the first place if he wasnt perving ... FREAKO!

not talking about this guy in particular but generally men and women should know about the issues concerning the other so they can teach their wife/husband/siblings/children etc, I think.

Also I don't think you have to really stare to notice the make up, sometimes (or generally) it just noticeable.

This is true. Theres a girl at uni that reminds me of an Egyptian pharaoh..scary...

MuslimBro โ€” Sun, 19 Jun 2011 - 06:57

YouI think there is a hadith on the line of "God is beautiful and likes beautiful things".

Indeed Allah is beautiful and He loves beauty.

What are people arguing about?

Bilan โ€” Sun, 19 Jun 2011 - 12:13

ThE pOwEr Of SiLeNcE

bilanTheres a girl at uni that reminds me of an Egyptian pharaoh..scary...

random? how/why?

Tisnt random. its cos of the way she does her make up

MuslimSister โ€” Mon, 20 Jun 2011 - 16:53

My issue with make up is - the lack of it.

For some bizzare reason, whenever I bump into my friends from my school days I'm amazed at how much they have let themselves go. I'm not implying that people should still look like the thin size 8, pretty girls they used to look like when they were in school...I understand it can be hard after kids etc

But when you're married dont you know have a reason to make even more of an effort? dont you now have someone to impress? the girls who used to make so much effort before marriage, make zero effort after marriage.

im not suggesting that people were it out of the house. but the whole point of make up is to enhance. use it. when applied properly it can even out your complexion and make your eyes appear bigger, brighter etc etc

there's this thing ive seen with muslim women (esp the ones in the west) they stop making the effort when they get married or when they become practsing. or both. why?

In this side of the world, the Arab women are the ones who are covered from head to toe and even have their faces covered...but underneath their abayah they are groomed from head to toe.

IMO its important to make the most of what you have.